Cultural Competency

­
23 07, 2015

How missing data can perpetuate injustice

By |July 23rd, 2015|Data and Statistics, Evidence-Based Decision Making, Cultural Competency|0 Comments

I had the opportunity recently to attend a solidarity rally in support of the Charleston 9 at First A.M.E. Church in Seattle. The room, though packed and sweltering, was filled with an overwhelming sense of a community unifying for change. It was powerful. Among the speakers was Dr. Sheley Secrest with the Seattle- King County NAACP. Dr. Secrest’s work focuses on economic development, and she spoke of a meeting at Boeing in the wake of significant recent layoffs. When she asked about data on who was being laid off – by race, hire date, and so on – she was told “Boeing doesn’t track that information.” For me, Dr. Secrest’s observation resonated as another example of data (or in this case, its absence) being used as a weapon. In The Current we recently reflected on the weaponization of data as part of a conversation with our friends and colleagues, Vu Le and Dr. Jondou Chen. Data can be weaponized, as well as the absence of data – and in some ways, this latter form is more insidious. […]

6 07, 2015

The weaponization of data: With great power comes great responsibility

By |July 6th, 2015|Evaluation, Data and Statistics, Cultural Competency|0 Comments

For the past few years our friend Vu Le of Rainier Valley Corps has been publishing a terrific blog called Nonprofit with Balls. If you don’t already know Vu, the title gives you a clue about his provocative ideas. A seasoned nonprofit leader, Vu has an unorthodox take on how the nonprofit world actually works—and lots of disruptive (in a good way) ideas about how it could work better. Vu recently posted a blog entry that got our attention here at TrueBearing: Weaponized data: How the obsession with data has been hurting marginalized communities. It’s a thought-provoking read for anyone involved in the nonprofit, public or grantmaking sectors, so all you unicorns out there go ahead and click on the link to read his post. I guarantee you’ll chuckle at least twice- and you’ll get the reference to unicorns. I’ll wait. Back already? OK. For those of you who didn’t bother to click the link, here is a 30,000-foot overview of Vu’s post: “Data can be used for good or for evil.” While acknowledging the power of skillfully used data and its benefits to both nonprofits and grantmakers, Vu nails ten distinct ways in which data can be—and too often has been—used to obscure rather than to illuminate, to diminish the richness of our understanding of nonprofit performance, and to maintain the power status quo in a way that marginalizes and sometimes even pathologizes entire communities. […]